The Point Of View Guide For Speakers

Philip Morgan
https://philipmorgan.net

Copyright © 2026 Philip Morgan
All Rights Reserved

v1.0, 2026

Dedicated to those who are willing to stick their neck out in service of their audience’s improvement.

1: Introduction

A point of view is an idea you wish your audience would buy into because their buy-in would make things better for them.

Each part of that sentence has something important to tell us about point of view (POV), so we’ll examine each part in turn.

NOTE: I wonder if each H2 below could have the entire definition but with the part that is currently all caps in each H2 bolded or bold+all caps instead. Might make it more obvious that we’re walking through the key parts of the sentence one part at a time.

A point of view is an IDEA

We can think of a POV literally as where you stand and what you see from there, but here it’s more useful to think of a POV as an idea. Ideas can be big or small, important or trivial, and simple or complex.

Ideas don’t create mountains or trees, but they have created compound interest, the Internet, copyright law, the 2008 financial crisis, the public school system, vacuum cleaners, cookie consent pop-ups, and sewing needles. Some ideas are toxins, yet so much of what makes modern life comfortable, enjoyable, beautiful, and even possible started as an idea.

Ideas can be slightly better ways to do things: optimizations. Or they can be profoundly different ways to do things: transformations. They can be codifications of observations: “handwashing seems to reduce deaths during childbirth”. Or they can be expressions of ideals or imagination: “humans could live and thrive on planets other than Earth”.

Ideas can be abstract and sweeping: “management is either an act of service or it fails”. Or they can be specific and applied: “managers should check in with every direct report on Mondays and Fridays”.

Your point of view can have any of these qualities. Good points of view are not limited to “big ideas”.

A point of view is an idea that you WISH

We only wish for that which could be, but has not yet happened. The fulfillment of a wish quenches its flame. Dictionary definitions of wish are peppered with the language of poetry: want, desire, hope, longing.

What idea matters enough that you feel desire, hope… or longing about its fate? Maybe no idea so moves you. But what ideas do you keep returning to? What ideas would you want to discuss with a friend? Or defend? Or make sure someone you were mentoring understood? What ideas would you want to apply to a client project because they’ve proved effective?

There are countless ideas. But only a few will matter enough to you to become part of your point of view.

A point of view is an idea that you wish YOUR AUDIENCE

Just as your speaking exists to serve an audience, your point of view exists to help that audience make progress. Your audience reaps the primary benefits of your POV; you reap the secondary benefits (better talks, more fame, etc.). Identifying, clarifying, and articulating your point of view is, first and foremost, an act of service to your audience.

A point of view is an idea that you wish your audience would BUY INTO

Buy-in is an emotional or intellectual transaction. We trade our previous way of thinking about, seeing, or doing something for one we deem better or more useful. We give up our POV and buy into someone else’s.

Buy-in can’t be forced. It’s an invitation combined with persuasion, reasoned argument, or both.

A point of view is an idea that you wish your audience would buy into BECAUSE

Some people stumble into a great point of view, sharpen it, and become known for it – all without thinking much about the process. The rest of us need a reason to go to all this trouble.

Why read a book on point of view? Why do the exercises this author suggests? Why put an argument in front of your audience and try to persuade them?

I’ve noticed four reasons we want a strong POV enough to work through the discomfort of developing one:

The most powerful, sustainable reason to want a point of view, however, isn’t about you at all.

A point of view is an idea that you wish your audience would buy into because their buy-in would MAKE THINGS BETTER FOR THEM.

The most powerful, sustainable reason to want a point of view is that it gives you a shot at making things better for those you serve. Your audience.

Being able to clearly articulate and defend a point of view helps you stand out as a speaker. But unless your POV addresses your audience’s needs and progress, standing out won’t make it relevant or compelling to them.

Good points of view attract attention. This can be a very good thing for you. But if that attention doesn’t benefit your audience, your POV isn’t built on a long-lasting foundation.

The larger audience or market you serve is the ecosystem you exist within. A POV that centers the health of that ecosystem can also benefit you and your speaking career over time.

It’s for your audience that you read this book, do the exercises, and endure the discomfort. It’s for them that you share the thinking that invites their buy-in.

POV is not just for missionaries and thought leaders

The way I’ve described POV here suggests a strong undercurrent of “missionary zeal”. It would be easy to conclude that only extroverts, thought leaders, or people trying to build a huge audience need to care about POV. But POV is more broadly useful than that.

If you’re having difficulty seeing how POV could be relevant to anybody other than missionaries and thought leaders, you may have made some assumptions:

You do not need to set out to transform your profession or attract a huge audience. An idea can be useful enough to build a talk around because it helps a particular group make a better decision. For example:

These three ideas are relatively modest in scope. Each makes a specific recommendation to a particular audience, with a clear benefit in mind. That’s enough to build a useful point of view around.

POV is not just for visionaries and “futurists”

A point of view is an idea you wish your audience would buy into. This framing might suggest that having a POV means seeing far into the future, then using that vision and overpowering charisma to draw your market toward a future state. Some do this, but you don’t have to.

The myth: You need futuristic vision. You need to see tomorrow, then use charisma to drag people toward it.

The reality: Most strong POVs come from empathetic frustration. You notice specific ways your audience underperforms their potential or self-sabotages. To them, you might look like a visionary—someone pulling them forward from the past. But you aren’t seeing the future. You’re simply illuminating a gap in their growth and helping them reach what’s already possible.

The exception: Some points of view do look beyond what even the most advanced members of your market have achieved. But this truly visionary quality is optional. You don’t need it to have a good POV.

POV can be a tidy hierarchy or a rowdy street gang

Thus far I’ve been discussing point of view in the singular: “a point of view”. This suggests that you have only one idea you wish your audience would buy into, or that your ideas neatly arrange themselves into a hierarchy with a unifying “umbrella idea” at the apex. If that’s how your points of view work, great, but it’s not the only way.

Some folks have several great points of view that serve the same market or audience but have little else in common. This is the “rowdy street gang” of POV. The “gang” has, at best, a loosely defined, fluid hierarchy, and its purpose is similarly loose and fluid. If this is how POV works for you, also great! You can benefit from POV without organizing your ideas into a tidy hierarchy.

Seth Godin is a good example here. Perhaps earlier in his career his points of view could have fit into a tidy hierarchy around some central idea of generosity in marketing, or permission marketing. His current work covers a much wider range, from education and schooling to running effective meetings. This is POV-as-rowdy-street-gang. Forcing this gang into a neat hierarchy under one “apex POV” would mean pruning an otherwise potent collective.

Why developing a POV can feel difficult

You may be comfortable sharing what you know. You can explain your expertise, tell stories from your life, or describe what worked in a particular situation. Developing a point of view asks you to go further: what do you wish your audience would buy into because it would make things better for them?

Your experience happened within a context you know intimately. You know the circumstances, the constraints, and the choices available to you. Your audience brings many different contexts. What helped you might help some of them, need adapting for others, and be entirely wrong for a few.

A visual example: I made the photographs below while traveling to Atlanta, Georgia, to give a talk on point of view. The first shows a single building; the second is an aerial view of the city.

Street-level view of a building in Atlanta, illustrating one specific context.

What can we say that is both useful and true about the mall housed in this one building? Lots of things, probably!

Aerial view of Atlanta, showing the many contexts across a city.

What can we say that is both useful and true about all of Atlanta, with its businesses, residences, government buildings, transportation networks, parks, and on and on? Let those questions sink in for a moment. You’ll feel the difference between describing one particular context and articulating an idea that could help across many contexts.

That’s where articulating a POV can feel uncomfortable. You’re moving from “here’s what happened” to “here’s an idea I believe would help you.” That requires judgment about how far your experience reaches, what supports your idea, and where its limits lie.

You don’t need an idea that works for everybody. You need a clear sense of whom it serves, how it helps, and why you believe it deserves their consideration.

POV is profitable, risky, and speculative

Let’s think about profit broadly: both the money you earn and the shared benefit you want your POV to create for your audience and your business.

Wanting your audience to buy into an idea for their benefit is audacious. I mean, who are you (or I, for that matter) to say what’s best for someone else? If the idea your POV is based on is so great, wouldn’t that be self-evident to your audience?

A POV built around an idea that matters to you is consequential. One possible consequence is that you repel people who don’t buy in. That’s part of the risk of going down this POV road.

You can’t have the profit of POV without some risk.

POV is also speculative. No matter how great your POV feels during those early days of identifying and clarifying it, you don’t yet know how useful it will be to your audience.

I hope that defining POV as an idea you want others to buy into for their benefit encourages you to cultivate points of view that create this kind of shared profit. But there are few guarantees in life, and the ultimate success of your POV is no exception.


The relevant POV from my rowdy street gang here – the idea I wish you’d buy into: you would benefit from having a clear, incisive POV. In advocating this POV, I join some esteemed company:

A point of view

That’s the difference between saying, “what would you like me to do,” and “I think we should do this, not that.”

A point of view is the difference between a job and a career.

It’s the difference between being a cog and making an impact.

Having a point of view is different from always being correct. No one is always correct.

Hiding because you’re not sure merely makes you invisible.

—Seth Godin, https://seths.blog/2017/12/a-point-of-view

• • •

Your audience showed up to hear you speak. They’re sitting there to learn your point of view, and you should clearly and completely articulate it.

—Nancy Duarte, Resonate, chapter 4, “The Big Idea”

• • •

Make your idea worth sharing. By that I mean, ask yourself the question: “Who does this idea benefit?”

—Chris Anderson, TED’s secret to great public speaking (7:06)

In this book, I hope to help you develop what you’ve got now — probably the raw material for a POV — into a clear, incisive point of view that helps you create more value and stand apart from the crowd.

Let’s get started.

2: How Does A Point Of View Work?

In the previous chapter, we defined a point of view as an idea you wish your audience would buy into because their buy-in would make things better for them. That definition tells us what a POV is and whom it serves. Now we’ll look at how it works: what makes the idea relevant, what adopting it might help people achieve, and how your perspective shapes its expression.

Your POV will usually contain a claim about what is true or how something should be done. Your argument supports that claim and gives people reasons to buy in. The idea is what you want them to adopt; the argument helps them understand why they should.

Point-of-view framework connecting an idea or claim with audience relevance, outcomes, perspective, argument style, status, and change style.

This diagram’s “Argument/Claim” identifies the idea you are asking your audience to buy into. We’ll examine that idea and the factors surrounding it below.

The Functions Of A Point Of View

A point of view actually does stuff in the world, including in your relationships with audiences and the people who book you. A POV can work in four ways.

  1. Differentiation: Many speakers cover the same broad topic you do, but few will bring exactly your perspective on how the audience could make progress. A point of view helps you stand out.

  2. Service: A good point of view helps your audience understand what could improve and how to move toward it.

  3. Filtering: Because your POV contains a claim that reasonable people could disagree with, it helps you and event organizers recognize when an engagement is a poor fit.

  4. Positioning: A POV positions you as a thinker or educator rather than an entertainer.

The Components Of A Point Of View

Most good points of view emerge organically from your desire to serve your audience. As I walk you through their components, don’t get pulled into thinking you can construct a POV from a box of parts. You don’t need to understand exactly how a point of view works, but some familiarity with its components can help.

The Central Elements

There are three central elements to a point of view.

1) Idea/Claim: At the center of a POV is the idea you want your audience to buy into. You can express it as a claim about what is true or how something should be done:

There are plenty of variations. “How we should do X” could become “Why Y is holding us back and what we should do about it”. The power of a POV is not its precise grammatical structure but the usefulness of the idea to the people you hope will adopt it. Your argument gives them reasons to consider that idea: experience, evidence, and an explanation of how it could help.

An audience can agree with an idea without having fully understood its implications or put it into practice. Your POV might challenge their beliefs, but it might also clarify something they already suspect, or help them act on something they already believe. The important question is what their buy-in would make possible.

2) Relevance: A good point of view is relevant to your audience’s needs, problems, aspirations, or purpose. My point of view on infrastructure in rural America is probably not relevant to your concerns, and that’s fine! I’d be foolish to wish otherwise. As the diagram above shows, a good point of view’s central idea intersects with its audience’s concerns. Your supporting argument needs to make that connection clear.

3) Outcome: A good point of view aims toward a desirable outcome for your audience. What could improve if they bought into the idea and applied it? The outcome might be a better decision, a more useful way of understanding a problem, or a change in how they do something. Be clear about the benefit you hope the idea will create without assuming that one talk will deliver it for everyone.

Ron Baker, who formerly practiced as a CPA, offers a useful example of all three elements. His idea is that professional firms should price around the value they create for clients rather than the hours they work.4 That’s relevant to attorneys, accountants, and other professionals who have to explain what their help is worth. An hourly rate tells a client what an hour costs; it doesn’t tell them what solving their problem is worth. Baker wants firms to have that conversation before the work begins. The intended outcome is clearer expectations about value, scope, and price, with both parties knowing what they’ve agreed to.

A POV can advocate incremental improvement or fundamental change. Some audiences need to rethink how they see or do something; others need a useful adjustment they can try within their existing constraints. Both are worthwhile aims for your speaking.

The Contextual Elements

There are four contextual elements to a point of view. Because a POV emerges from a person who cares about an audience’s progress, it carries that person’s distinctive qualities, like a fingerprint. If Ron Baker and I cared passionately about the same audience and outcome, we would still bring different points of view because we are different people. That difference comes from context. The four contextual factors are:

1) Perspective: You stand somewhere in life; you can’t help but do so. Where you stand shapes what you see. Someone who finds standardized tests easy sees annoying but trivial games standing between them and opportunity. Someone who struggles with those tests sees heavily guarded doors to the same opportunities. Same thing, different perspective.

An industry outsider might see an opportunity to do things better if only X; an insider might remember failed attempts at variations of X and see ten reasons not to try it.

A scientist sees a need to evaluate support for a new initiative with a quantitative survey; a visionary sees a need to rally the troops with an inspiring afternoon workshop.

The term “point of view” draws attention to where you stand: it shapes what you see and how you argue for change. Becoming aware of your perspective invites some important questions:

These two 19th-century thought leaders provide a good example of perspective.

Portraits of Ignaz Semmelweis on the left and Silas Weir Mitchell on the right.

Ignaz Semmelweis (left, above) was born in Hungary in 1818. As a chief resident at Vienna General Hospital, he and others noticed that one maternity clinic’s mortality rate was about three times the other’s. The deadlier clinic was staffed by medical students who also dissected cadavers; the other by midwives who did not. Semmelweis theorized that “cadaverous material” caused the infections behind the higher mortality. He convinced the students to adopt handwashing, and the mortality rate immediately dropped to match the other clinic’s.

Semmelweis began campaigning for other practitioners to adopt handwashing; his perspective was rooted in data, and he used data from his experience at Vienna General Hospital to support his argument. He was ignored, rejected, and ridiculed by the medical establishment at the time. Semmelweis was ultimately driven mad by his quest, committed to an insane asylum by his peers in 1865, and was beaten severely by the asylum guards. He died of an infection two weeks later at age 47. (Think twice before you decide that thought leadership is right for you!)

Semmelweis died in the year the US Civil War ended. Silas Weir Mitchell, born in Philadelphia in 1829, treated soldiers who had lost limbs to gunfire or lifesaving field amputations. Mitchell coined the term “phantom limb” to help explain pain felt in a limb that was no longer there. He didn’t discover the phenomenon, but — as thought leaders often do — gave it a sticky name. He also wrote “The Case of George Dedlow” for The Atlantic, a fictional story about a Civil War survivor who had lost all four limbs and suffered phantom limb pain. The story helped the idea gain acceptance within medicine and the broader culture.

Semmelweis leaned toward data in his perspective. Mitchell drew on experience and brought it to life with a fictional story. If you ever think data is automatically more powerful than experience, remember this contrast. Whether your perspective comes from data or experience, look for the ways it gives your POV power.

(Source: Wikipedia and https://www.history.com/news/the-civil-war-doctor-who-proved-phantom-limb-pain-was-real)

2) Argument Style: As you invite buy-in to your idea, you are making and supporting an argument. Your style — the way you phrase things, the examples you use, the expectations you have of your audience — falls somewhere on a spectrum from forceful and disruptive to gentle and evolutionary. That style isn’t fixed; you can adjust it. What argument style would best serve your audience’s interests?

3) Status: Your status, as your audience perceives it, comes partly from how you present yourself and partly from your history and perspective. I tend to think of a status spectrum running from pedigreed insiders on one end to expert outsiders on the other. For insiders, listeners may recognize credibility in your research, your experience doing the work they do, or your experience navigating a challenge they face. An outsider may bring a useful perspective precisely because they haven’t spent a career within the audience’s field. Framing that background can help: “I don’t have a background in X, but that also means I’m not steeped in its bad habits.” Don’t get too in your head about it, but do ask: what does your background help this audience trust you to speak about, and how can you use that credibility in their best interests?

4) Change Style: Finally, as you help listeners consider adopting your idea, you’ll have a natural change style — a way of helping them approach uncertainty, status quo bias, risk, discomfort, institutional inertia, and communication friction. Your argument style shapes how you make the case; your change style shapes how you help people put the idea into practice. You might invite a small experiment, help listeners anticipate obstacles, or encourage them to question a familiar way of doing things.

Like your argument style, your change style can develop with experience and deliberate practice. You may have only a short time with an audience, while the practical work of change happens afterward. Consider what would help listeners take a useful next step within the constraints they will return to, and whether that approach is coherent with your idea, your argument style, and their needs.

Together, the three central elements of your POV (idea/claim, relevance, and outcome) and the four contextual elements (perspective, argument style, status, and change style) give it the distinctiveness of a human fingerprint. Don’t get in your head about optimizing each element. I hope understanding them helps you communicate the idea more effectively and support your audience’s progress.

Point-of-view framework connecting an idea or claim with audience relevance, outcomes, perspective, argument style, status, and change style.

(This is the same diagram, repeated for convenience now that we’ve examined every one of its components.)

3: Cultivating A POV

You can’t force a plant to grow. But you can create conditions that help it grow. Likewise with POV.

Developing Your Point Of View

Points of view emerge from a living relationship between you, your concern for your market, and your market itself. Can points of view instead be engineered? Manufactured?

You can nurture points of view into being. You can create the conditions that help one emerge, sift a mess of opinions for good “POV material”, and polish a raw POV into something more effective. But I don’t think you can engineer or manufacture a POV from nothing. That raises the question: what is the something you need to nurture one?

You have to care about your audience’s improvement. In my experience, that care does more to produce an effective POV than expertise or fame alone.

In other words, a good POV grows out of caring about your audience’s wellbeing. There’s quite a lot to say about POV itself, but its starting point is simple: care enough to stick your neck out with a thoughtful perspective on what would make things better for those you serve.

Maybe you care about your audience’s improvement but don’t think you have a great POV. You probably do have “POV raw material”; most people who’ve been around the block a time or two do. This chapter will help you surface that material, including ideas buried deeper in your thinking, and filter it for promising candidates.

The POVSpace

When I run workshops on point of view, I ask participants to locate themselves in a “POVSpace” with four axes. Most tell me they enjoy and benefit from this exercise, but it can be challenging because it invites a kind of self-reflection that’s new to many of us.

The POVSpace map offers a way to reflect on the perspective and approach you bring to your POV. As you look at this map, you are thinking about your usual approach to things as an area within that map. To use the analogy of a map of the United States, you are thinking in terms of a state, not a single city. It’s similar to personality: most of us fall somewhere between introversion and extroversion, and how we express those qualities can vary.

Here are the four elements of POVSpace, which you will recognize from the previous chapter:

Yes, I know reality is complex and nuanced in ways this map can’t represent. You may emphasize data with one audience and experience with another, or use a different change style with people encountering your idea for the first time. You can be an insider to one group and an outsider to another. The map helps you recognize your usual “center of gravity” and consider how you express the idea in a particular talk. Asking which pole your approach is closer to can be clarifying; the artificial simplicity of this map has value in helping you understand yourself.

Map Yourself On The POVSpace Map

Take some time to reflect and map your POV. Here’s how.

The easiest way to explain this is to show you a completed POVSpace Map and explain how it was created. Here’s an example from surgeon and The Checklist Manifesto author Atul Gawande, drawing from his 2012 TED talk on redesigning medical care.5 I’m mapping his argument that good care requires coordinated, reliable systems as well as skilled individuals. As with the other maps below, this is my impression of his public work, not his own description of his POV.

Illustrative POVSpace map for Atul Gawande’s argument about building reliable systems of care.

In this example, I’ve mapped Gawande’s POV as:

A solid line means pedigreed insider; dashed means expert outsider. Sharp corners mean a disruptive change style; rounded corners mean evolutionary. The rectangle shows an approximate range along the perspective and agenda axes. (This distinction works in both color and in monochrome.)

If at this point you understand how to use this map, you might go ahead and fill one out for yourself. A blank map appears below; you can also open or save a copy to annotate at philipmorgan.net/povspacemap/.

If you’d like to see a few more example maps, here are my impressions of four other people’s public work.

Illustrative POVSpace map for Sharon Toerek’s advice on addressing freelance intellectual-property ownership early.

Attorney Sharon Toerek helps agency owners address ownership and usage rights before freelance work creates a problem.7 I would map this particular argument toward experience and optimization: she draws on recurring situations in agency work and recommends a practical preparatory process, not a wholesale rebuilding of the business. That is a gentle, evolutionary approach to change. Her involvement in the agency community gives her insider standing as well as legal expertise.

Illustrative POVSpace map for Geni Whitehouse’s work on making winery cost information useful.

CPA and winery adviser Geni Whitehouse encourages winery teams to capture and allocate costs throughout the year.8 I would map this as practical optimization with an evolutionary change style: she’s improving an ongoing workflow, not replacing it. Her argument blends advising experience with attention to financial information—the emphasis is on making existing decisions work better. Her CPA background and experience advising wineries give her insider standing in the financial side of this industry. And working with numbers, by itself, doesn’t make an argument the product of a research study.

Illustrative POVSpace map for Sarah Susanka’s argument about rethinking what makes a better house.

Architect Sarah Susanka asks homeowners to reconsider what makes a better house.9,10 Her Not So Big approach puts quality and the way people actually live ahead of additional square footage. Not So Big need not mean small. I would map that as a transformational agenda introduced through a gentle, practical invitation to rethink design choices. Her argument draws on architectural experience and design judgment, and her background as an architect gives her insider standing in the subject.

Illustrative POVSpace map for Ron Baker’s argument for replacing hourly billing with value pricing.

Ron Baker, who formerly practiced as a CPA, argues for eliminating hourly billing and timesheets in professional firms.11 That is a transformational agenda: he wants firms to organize pricing around client value rather than hours worked. His stated aim and his remark that “the only place time spent should matter is in prison” give this argument a disruptive edge. I would map it toward experience and economic reasoning, with insider credibility rooted in his accounting background.12

Susanka and Baker both ask their audiences to rethink a basic measure of success: the size of a house or the hours a professional works. Their change agendas are transformational, but their change styles differ. Susanka offers a gentle invitation to reconsider; Baker directly challenges practices he wants to eliminate. You can seek a profound change without adopting a disruptive style, and a disruptive style does not require a loud delivery.

All right, here is that blank POVSpace map. You can mark it on paper or annotate an electronic copy. You can’t do this mapping thing wrong. The questions it raises can be productive even if you can’t answer them immediately, so give it a try!

Blank POVSpace map with experience-to-data and transformation-to-optimization axes, plus argument-style and status keys.

Surfacing POV Raw Material

A clearer sense of where you’re coming from will help you use the following questions to surface “raw material”: ideas, opinions, and beliefs you might want your audience to buy into. These are the rough precursors to a sharper POV.

I’ve grouped these questions by the two primary axes of the POVSpace Map: Data vs. Experience and Transformation vs. Optimization. Someone who argues mainly from data and seeks incremental improvement, for example, would start with the Data-Based Optimizer questions. Of course you can explore all the questions, wherever they’re grouped. :) They’re simple and open-ended to give your thinking a jumping-off point.

Start by thinking about the larger audience you hope to help. Your raw material might come from research, work, personal experience, or conversations with people from that audience. Client engagements can be one source, but you don’t need a consulting practice to have useful experience. Then consider a particular talk: which of these ideas could help those listeners, and what would you need to understand about their circumstances?

Data-Based Optimizer

  1. What does your data — or someone else’s — tell you about the problems your audience faces?
  2. How might your data run counter to conventional wisdom?
  3. How might your data support conventional wisdom?
  4. Does your data suggest a sequence for making progress that keeps risk low?

Data-Based Transformer

  1. What “icebergs” does your data suggest your audience is heading toward? (Imagine if the Titanic had been able to detect the iceberg ahead.)
  2. Do you have data on fundamental transformations in people’s lives, organizations, or communities that your audience could learn from? Can it tell the story of those successes?
  3. Elite segments of military forces have entrance tests with objective criteria. Does your data suggest a similar set of “go/no-go” criteria for potential transformation?

Experience-Based Optimizer

In the following questions, I’ll call the traits or accomplishments your audience admires “ideals”. Commercially successful creativity, for example, might be a prominent ideal in marketing but less so in finance.

  1. Who does your audience put on a pedestal? These might be people or companies.
  2. Why does your audience admire them? Which traits or accomplishments stand out?
  3. What ideals represent the “common sense” or obviously desired states of being for your audience? (ex: Within team environments, diversity, alignment, and “great culture” are often considered self-evidently desirable states to work towards.)
  4. What behavioral ideals match the values or norms of your sector? (ex: Within academia and science, objectivity and elevating the pursuit of truth over personal gain are idealized.)
  5. Which people, companies, or institutions outside your audience also match the ideals you’ve listed?
  6. What stories about challenge and change do you hear over and over from your audience? (Apple could almost spin up a profitable division licensing the stories associated with its brand. They’ve become lore and legend.)

Experience-Based Transformer

  1. Who inspires strong admiration in your audience, even if that person is far removed from their day-to-day reality?
  2. What represents a “pure” or “Platonic” path of improvement for your audience?
  3. When your audience compares their sector with another, which sector do they choose, and why?
  4. Are there versions of “The Hero’s Journey” that your audience often repeats or finds especially compelling?

More General Question Prompts

These prompts may also be useful, whatever your perspective.

Pattern Of Stupidity

You might notice a pattern of stupidity among the people you hope to help. Later, I’ll ask you to run all your POV ideas through an “empathy filter”. For now, I’ll use blunt language like “stupid” to remind you that you’re looking for big, motivating issues to build your POV around.

  1. Are the people you hope to help making objectively bad decisions?
  2. Where are they not doing the hard work of being well-informed and thoughtful?
  3. Where are they misunderstanding cause and effect?
  4. Where are they following the herd rather than thinking for themselves?

Frustration Or Dissatisfaction

You might notice patterns of frustration within your larger audience, or you may feel frustration on their behalf. These can be pointers towards a point of view.

  1. Where are the people you hope to help being misled?
  2. Where are they missing low-hanging fruit?
  3. What do they aspire to?
  4. Where do they face difficult external headwinds?
  5. What have they been putting up with or enduring?

Experience/Data

You may notice patterns in your work, personal experience, research, or conversations with audiences. These can be the precursors to good POV candidates.

  1. What patterns are quite clear to you?
  2. What stories from your experience come up over and over again when talking with people you hope to help?
  3. If you had to give a conference talk based only on your experience, what idea would you want the audience to take from it?
  4. What “icebergs” does your data warn about?

The Empathy Filter

Run every POV idea through an “empathy filter”. By empathy, I don’t mean you need to feel warm, tender, gushy feelings toward your audience. I mean wanting to make things better for them, seeing things from their perspective, and trusting that acting in their interests can also serve yours. In this book, empathy is more about stewardship of your audience’s interests than a strongly felt emotion (though it can be both).

  1. Who benefits from buying into this POV?
  2. How difficult is it to implement this POV?
  3. What good reasons or counterarguments explain why this POV hasn’t already been adopted?
  4. What good-faith misinterpretations of this POV exist?

Consider these questions for your larger audience and for the people attending a particular talk. An idea can be useful in general yet poorly suited to the circumstances of that room. What would you need to learn, explain, or adapt for those listeners?

Signals

The other elements of POVSpace — your status with your audience and your change style — also operate through “signals”: your phrasing, tone of voice, and other subtle choices.

Signaling Pedigree

Here are ways to signal your pedigree without clumsily saying, “You should listen to me because of my pedigree”:

Name-Dropping: I don’t mean this in a negative sense here. What famous-to-your-audience people are you on a first-name basis with? Who do you have access to? There are clumsy ways to name-drop, but there are also artful ways to do this.

“When I was…”: A prime example: “When I was at McKinsey, blah blah blah.” This is the ol’ authority-by-association move. Overuse will get people’s eyes rolling, but used artfully, it can transfer some authority from the respected company, institution, or context to you.

“War Stories”: Here you are presenting stories from your work that establish your experience while helping the audience understand your point of view. Attorney Sharon Toerek describes having to track down freelancers for assignments of rights after their work became a client’s brand identity. The missing paperwork mattered when that client became involved in an M&A transaction. For an audience of agency owners, the story makes her relevant experience visible while supporting her recommendation to settle ownership arrangements early.13 She does not need to name the client for the lesson to land home.

Style Of Dress can send signals about pedigree.

There are subtler forms of signaling, too:

Diction: Earlier in my career, I did technical writing for an agency that worked extensively with Microsoft. Every longtime Microsoft manager I interacted with spoke very quickly, under-enunciating syllables and almost tripping over their words. (Ben Thompson’s Conversations With Tyler interview offers a good example of this style of diction.) I suspect some US presidents have deliberately used speech that signals a lack of pedigree to seem more relatable. Don’t get too in your head about this, but consider how leaning into or away from your natural diction might send the signal you want.

Jargon And Phraseology: Jargon can signal your “insiderness” or “outsiderness”. Language that’s opaque to some listeners may signal shared experience to others.

Signaling Experience

You can demonstrate expertise by presenting it. But often you first need to earn enough attention to make your case. That’s when you may need to signal that you have relevant, valuable expertise.

The way this is done in books like Good To Great is to talk about impressively large numbers: the number of file drawers filled by the book’s source material, the number of hours spent collecting and analyzing it, and so on. Despite that particular book’s fundamental methodological flaw, the basic authority-building approach of saying “I’ve looked at way more data than you have” is sound. Of course you wouldn’t say those exact words – that comes across as bluntly arrogant – but you can often earn a hearing for your POV with some variation of this opening gambit.

This gambit combines well with an “I’m not any smarter than you, but after looking at this much data, X is obvious, even to me” message. It blends self-deprecating humility (“it’s obvious even to an ordinary intellect like mine”) with an appeal to authority (“I’ve looked at more data”).

Another framing takes the opposite approach. Rather than emphasizing the sheer weight of your data or experience, you point to a pattern few others have noticed. You’ve discovered a secret. Curiosity may give you an opening to support that insight with data, experience, or both.

Deep experience is the usual headwaters of expert confidence, so confidence can signal that experience. Many of us treat it as a proxy for wisdom. This heuristic is too easily hacked — thus the power of the confidence scheme. Remember that deep expertise produces both confidence and caution. As an expert outsider, you can lead with confidence and follow with caution and caveats.

Signaling A Disrupter Change Style

The following will signal a disruptive change style:

Signaling An Evolver Change Style

The following will signal a more gentle, evolutionary change style:

Ideation

In the workshop I’ve run on POV, I ask participants to make a personal copy of this Google Doc and freewrite their way through the set of questions that matches their POVSpace location: philipmorgan.net/povquestions. I encourage you to do the same now.

At this point, these can be just opinions. They don’t have to be polished POVs; trying for that level of refinement will get in the way of freewriting. Filtering and polishing come later.

Immediately afterward, list every opinion that might be relevant to the people you hope to reach through your speaking and other work. You’ll develop the promising ones into a POV “layer cake” later. If it’s easier to freewrite the list itself, do that.

Again, the worksheet: philipmorgan.net/povquestions.

Audience

I use the word audience to describe the people who encounter your POV. For a speaker, that includes both the listeners at a particular talk and the larger audience you hope to reach over time. Your larger audience is defined by the people you want to help and the concerns you want to help them address; it needn’t consist of people who already follow your work.

I’d like you to think about where your larger audience would lie on our POVSpace map. This will be a challenging and possibly frustrating exercise. They are people with differing backgrounds, purposes, and approaches to achieving those purposes. If the group is too broad to describe meaningfully, choose a more specific group within it to start with. Ask yourself: where is the center of gravity of their point of view? How do they see the world? What is their agenda for themselves? What is their change style?

Then make a second map for the audience of a particular talk, whether it’s an upcoming engagement or one you’d like to give. How do those listeners differ from the larger audience? What do they already know or believe? What matters to them now? What constraints might make it difficult for them to adopt or apply your idea?

Neither audience is a monolith, and even your best map will be an approximation. Note the differences within each group that matter to your idea. Talk with the organizer and, where possible, people from the audience to check your assumptions. The goal is a clearer understanding of whom you’re trying to help, rather than a diagram that pretends everyone thinks alike.

Overlaps/Tensions

Compare your location on the POVSpace map with each audience’s. How could the overlaps or differences help you make the idea useful to them?

You might imagine that any difference between your POV and your audience’s is a problem. I don’t think so. Both overlaps and differences can help you persuade, challenge, inspire, empathize, or connect.

For a particular talk, ask which beliefs you can build on, which you hope to challenge, and what listeners need to understand before the idea becomes useful. A difference might open up a productive conversation, or it might reveal that the idea doesn’t fit this audience. Agreement might give you a starting point for action, or it might mean you need to explore implications the audience hasn’t yet considered.

Over time, look across those encounters. What do different audiences find useful? Where do the same misunderstandings or objections recur? What have you learned that should change the idea itself? The work of getting really good at this can be the work of an entire career, and individual talks can give you opportunities to keep learning.

Filtering Your Opinions For Good POV Material

Freewriting through those questions should leave you with opinions of varying quality; these are your “POV candidates”. Avoiding self-editing gives you a better chance of discovering good stuff just outside your usual path of thinking. Now is the time to ruthlessly filter that list for promising POV material.

Below are some qualities of a good POV. Some you’ll want to maximize; others will help you judge how a candidate fits the people you serve and the work you want to develop.

Durability

Here are some questions that will help you evaluate the durability and potential longevity of a candidate POV:

For speakers, it’s also useful to distinguish repeated delivery from repeated exposure. You might give a talk about the same idea many times, with each audience encountering it for the first time. Meanwhile, people who follow your work over time may benefit from fresh examples, deeper exploration, and what you’ve learned since they first encountered the idea.

Neither situation requires inventing a new POV for every engagement. An idea can continue to serve new listeners while you develop a richer body of work around it.

A POV doesn’t have to last forever to be worth developing, but have a sense of its likely lifespan before you go all in.

Audience Benefit

To what extent is the candidate POV focused on audience benefit? If I were frustrated by listeners checking their phones during a talk, it would be tempting to cook up a POV about how audiences should pay more attention to speakers. But that idea could quite transparently flow from wanting a more comfortable experience on stage. What would those listeners gain by buying in? Their wellbeing and progress need to be at the center of the idea.14

Ask this for both audiences: what could the idea help your larger audience understand or do, and what would make it useful to the people attending a particular talk?

Saleability

Some people will agree with your POV immediately, or find it obvious because it closely matches theirs. Others will need time to buy in – to accept the idea and make it part of how they understand the world. That process can cost them effort or comfort even when no money changes hands.

This is the right place for a reminder of this well-known quote from Upton Sinclair:

It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it.

For structural reasons, some people will never buy into your POV. Maybe their job or revenue model depends on rejecting it. Perhaps they have no interest in updating their worldview or no incentive to endure even temporary cognitive dissonance. Others do have that motivation or interest. Your candidate POV may offer them an appealing possibility for growth, but buying in may require independent exploration or plain ol’ laborious thinking. How do you “sell” these folks on it?

How much evidence do you have for the candidate POV? Evidence can be data, but it doesn’t have to be. We humans also respond to stories about others’ experiences (anecdata).

What are the implications of adopting your candidate POV? Does it merely provide a new/better way of understanding the world, or will it require further action, a shift in identity, or deeper forms of change in order to fully buy in?

Your candidate POV may promise to solve a problem or improve the status quo. How attractive is that promise to your audience?

How realistic is the candidate POV’s explicit or implied promise? You don’t have to limit yourself to easily achievable promises, but consider how many people could achieve and benefit from the change you’re advocating.15

Fit With Your Speaking

Does this idea lend itself to the kind of speaking you want to do? Can you support it with material that helps listeners understand and use it? Does it invite the kinds of talks, workshops, or follow-on work you want to develop?

Consider both a particular engagement and your work over time. You might be able to communicate the idea usefully in a short talk, explore its application in a workshop, or develop its implications across writing and future talks. Which of those possibilities interests you, and which would serve the people you hope to help? You don’t need to pursue every form, but it’s useful to notice where the idea could lead.

Conversational Potential

The core of your POV is an idea you want your audience to buy into, and your argument gives them reasons to consider it. Ideally, the idea is a jumping-off point for a variety of conversations: questions during a talk, discussions afterward, exchanges with people who follow your work, and conversations among listeners themselves.

I can’t give you a formula, but consider each candidate’s potential to spur conversation. Someone might silently weigh your idea against their existing beliefs. People might discuss it across books, articles, and social media, or in person. I think a POV that leaves no room for conversation limits its own impact. I won’t try to prove that claim here; I’ll invite you to think it over, or discuss it with me if the opportunity arises.

What questions might your POV invite in a particular room? What would people want to discuss with one another afterward? Across your larger audience, which questions could sustain further exploration? Treat listener feedback as a chance to learn what is clear, what is disputed, and what needs more thought.

Coherence

A good POV fits the people you want to serve and the body of work you want to develop. This is obvious and easily forgotten. If you want to help people make practical, incremental improvements, you don’t need a sweeping transformational idea simply because it sounds more impressive on stage. And yet, social media in particular encourages us to make everything about ourselves. You don’t need a strong, unnuanced POV on every issue of the moment, even when those issues matter to your audience. Nor do you need to take your cues from whatever famous people in your field are talking about.

So it might be easy or sexy or popular to have a POV on X, but do you really care? (Also, a lot of these “of the moment” POVs are going to fail the durability test.) Do you want to keep speaking, learning, and developing material around this idea? Can you support it honestly and help listeners understand what adopting it would ask of them? If the POV is transformational, do you have the emotional budget to keep advocating for it and responding thoughtfully to resistance?

An idea might fit one event but have little connection to the work you want to build over time. Conversely, an idea central to your larger work might not serve a particular room. Consider both kinds of fit as you decide which candidates to develop.

In a way, coherence is the overarching quality because it brings so many of the others together. It asks: is this POV the right instrument to serve the people you care about and support the work you want to develop?

• • •

I realize this chapter of the book might feel a but “mechanical”. Laying out the questions as I have here shows how I approach helping someone formulate a POV. In practice, that work is more like a wide-ranging, messy conversation — sometimes frustrating, but usually an enjoyable mutual exploration. If this systematic approach feels cold or off-putting, find a “thought partner”: someone who can be a champion, critic, and co-developer of your thinking. Talk through this stuff with them.

4: Articulating A POV

How do you articulate a POV? How do you make it clear, compelling, and useful to your audience?

Experts with a strong POV often make articulating it look effortless. But there are patterns we can learn from them. These fall into two categories: 1) argument form, and 2) how that form is used over time.

Your POV is an idea you want your audience to buy into for their benefit. Your argument gives them reasons to consider it. Articulating your POV means making that idea understandable, supporting it, and helping people see what adopting it could mean for them. Your POV will have both stylistic and substantive distinctiveness. As a reminder:

Stylistic Distinctiveness:

Substantive Distinctiveness:

Your idea may resemble one that others advocate, but these stylistic and substantive qualities can make your POV distinctive to your audience, like an “intellectual fingerprint”.

Your POV needs a form people can understand and use. A great book offers more than words and ideas: its layout makes them easy to take in, and its design makes it pleasant to handle or read on a screen. In a talk, the sequence of ideas, the examples, and the connections between them serve a similar purpose. This is the POV’s form.

Form

Three forms for articulating a point of view: the layer cake, the hub and spoke, and principle and specifics.

A nearly infinite variety of rock songs can be based on just three guitar chords. Here I’ll describe three forms of argument you can mix and match as you articulate your POV. They don’t prescribe exactly how to arrange your words, and you may use several or all of them together.

Think of these forms as frameworks or even rules. As you gain mastery, you may move beyond the rules that helped you get there. For now, these three frameworks can give you a useful starting point.

1) The “Layer Cake” Framework

A point of view can be packaged into a three-layer structure:

Authors often have several versions of their bio, from two sentences to a page or more. The “layer cake” works similarly. Audio compression offers another analogy:

  1. The base layer is completely uncompressed, like a WAV file.
  2. The middle layer preserves more of the substance and reasoning than the headline does, but a paragraph inevitably leaves things out. Unlike the lossless compression of a FLAC file, it can’t preserve every detail.
  3. The headline uses lossy compression: it preserves vital information while discarding other detail. MP3 files do this.

Jonathan Stark’s point of view makes a useful example: it’s well constructed, vividly expressed, and about money, which many of us have strong feelings about. Those qualities make the patterns easier to notice. Here’s my summary using the layer cake framework. These are Jonathan’s ideas but my words. He’s a friend, and I’ve followed his work for years, so I believe I’m portraying his ideas faithfully.

• • •

  1. Headline layer: “Hourly billing is nuts.”
  2. Middle layer: Hourly billing hurts both service provider and client because it discourages speed and innovation. It deprives the provider of a fair share of high-value outcomes. The client doesn’t know the cost going in, so can’t judge the likely return on their investment. This is why hourly billing is nuts.
  3. Base layer: Jonathan develops this argument through a book,16 a long-running podcast he hosts,17 podcast guest appearances, and his email list.18 In other words, there’s an ocean of supporting argument — a body of work — at the base layer of his POV.

• • •

You can see the “lossy compression” in that headline, right? There aren’t enough words to support the argument or flesh out Jonathan’s core claim about hourly billing. The headline has a different job: to earn enough attention to introduce the middle layer. Whether it’s the title of a book, a talk, or something else, it needs to be true even though it’s incomplete. It also needs to be intriguing, surprising, or even repulsive (repelling people who have no chance of getting value from your POV can be a form of service!).

The middle layer aims to capture the essential elements of Jonathan’s argument. There’s still “compression”, but more reasoning is visible. Someone who feels a dissatisfaction with hourly billing they haven’t articulate may “feel seen” or have an “aha!” moment. Someone offended by the headline gets a thoughtful argument to debate. Both have a reason to explore the base layer: the ocean of content Jonathan freely shares to help his audience move away from hourly billing.

For a speaker, the layer cake is useful when preparing a talk. Can you state the idea concisely? Can you explain why it matters and give listeners a reason to consider it? What material supports it when someone wants to go deeper?

A particular talk draws from the base layer; it doesn’t need to contain everything you know. Choose the evidence, stories, counterarguments, and applications that help this audience understand and use the idea. Over time, your larger audience may encounter more of that supporting material across different talks and other work.

2) The Hub & Spoke Framework

In the hub & spoke framework, the hub is the POV and the spokes are implications of the POV. The implications of a POV are every significant variation of “X is true, therefore Y”.

I’m not sure I’d call this Blair Enns’ core POV, but it’s one I’ve heard him express multiple times: “Sales is not persuasion, it’s helping a prospect understand if there’s a fit with your services.” (My summary, not Blair’s words.) What are its implications — the therefore Ys of this X? An incomplete list:

  1. If sales is not fundamentally about persuasion, “being persuasive” might not be essential to selling well. What, then, makes an effective salesperson?
  2. If sales is about understanding fit, my lack of clarity about who makes a good client might be hurting my sales.
  3. If my sales close rate is low, could a better fit with the market’s needs help me improve it?

The spokes might be realizations that flow from the POV, effects of embracing it, or questions it raises.

When preparing a talk, choose the implications that matter to the people in that room. Which ones connect to their concerns? Which need explanation before listeners can act on the idea? You don’t need to cover every spoke in one talk.

Across talks to different audiences, you might explore different spokes while keeping the hub recognizable. If you fully explored the significant implications of your POV and wrote 1,500-word essays on each implication (and maybe one to three such essays on the core POV), you would have material for a book. The same exploration can also supply a series of talks or a workshop.

3) The Principle & Specifics Framework

The “principle & specifics” framework differs from hub & spoke in how you explore your POV’s implications. With hub & spoke, you develop a list up front, much as you’d outline a book before writing it. With principle & specifics, events supply examples, cases, and situations to which you can apply your POV’s principles. This framework is “event-driven”.

Even an ordinary life supplies material for analogies and teaching stories. Work, research, and conversations with audiences create even more. Each gives you opportunities to make an idea accessible through concrete situations.

For a particular talk, choose situations that help those listeners recognize what the idea means and how they could apply it. Make the connection explicit: what does this story or case help them understand? An analogy can illuminate an idea, but it doesn’t by itself establish that the idea is true. Over time, new situations can also help you discover the limits of the principle and where it needs refinement.

Because events take the place of an outline, this framework is less structured than hub & spoke. Use it to develop examples for a talk or keep exploring an idea across talks, writing, or recordings.

These aren’t the only three forms a POV can take, and there are variations of each. My purpose is to help you see the little “magician tricks” that skilled communicators use. You might read Jonathan Stark’s daily emails and think he’s smart and prolific (he is!) and that raw talent explains their quality. Now you may also see the principle & specifics framework at work. Recognizing these patterns in work you admire gives you something to try in your own.

What’s The Difference Between POV And Thought Leadership?

Elsewhere, I’ve described thought leadership as a protracted campaign of arguing for the change articulated in your POV. So where does POV end and thought leadership begin?

A POV is the idea you advocate. Thought leadership is sustained work to develop, support, and spread that idea. For a speaker, that work might connect a series of talks with research, writing, and conversations that help an audience understand and use the idea over time.

An individual talk can articulate a POV without belonging to a larger campaign. When you keep developing the idea, learning from particular audiences, and connecting those encounters into work that serves your larger audience, you’re doing the sustained work described here as thought leadership.

That work can support a speaking business, workshops, or other paid offerings. It can also serve educational, community, or other purposes. A complementary business model may help sustain it, but monetization isn’t what defines it.

5: Getting Started

“Philip, this is all great, but give me a process, please. Or at least a starting point.”

Ask and you shall receive. I’ve run a POV workshop for consultants several times. This “recipe” adapts what I learned there for speakers. Think of it as the “Getting Started Guide” that comes with a new tech product or piece of software.

The Process

1) Model Others’ POVs

A teacher can make a smart but hesitant student feel awkward by putting them on the spot in front of the class. We can do the same to ourselves with this POV work. Instead of diving headfirst into “what is my POV?”, start with “how do other people’s points of view work?”

Use the POVSpace Map to examine points of view you already know. If none come to mind, consider:

For a talk you know well, ask: what idea does the speaker want the audience to buy into? What argument supports it? How do the examples, emphasis, and invitation to act make it useful to those listeners? Then use POVSpace to examine the speaker’s approach.

Here’s a blank POVSpace map that you can print or annotate electronically: philipmorgan.net/povspacemap/.

You can’t do this mapping “wrong”. Grappling with its ambiguity is productive, so give it some good deep-thinking time!

2) POV Ideation

There are many ways to develop a good POV, but generally three phases:

  1. Generate a bunch of ideas of varying quality
  2. Filter those ideas for the ones that work well as a POV
  3. Keep refining the good ones and how you express them

Now is the right time to start the ideation and filtering work. Use the questions for surfacing raw material in chapter 3. Draw on work, life, research, and conversations with audiences as you generate ideas. Then use the empathy questions and other prompts and the POV filters to examine them.

The output you’re looking for is a shortlist of ideas you might want your audience to adopt for their benefit. They don’t need to be polished yet.

3) POV Prioritization

Shock value can make a POV memorable, but the most valuable points of view address your audience’s immediate concerns or long-term progress. Next, map your audience’s POV. Start with the larger group you hope to help through your speaking and other work. Then consider the listeners at an upcoming talk or one you’d like to give.

Use a separate blank POVSpace map for each audience, available at philipmorgan.net/povspacemap/. These maps are approximations; note the differences within each group that matter to your idea, and where you need to learn more.

Ask these questions at both audience scales. The overlaps and tensions will help you identify your most promising POV candidates.

  1. If there is a gap between your POV candidates and your audience’s POV:
    1. How might this gap challenge your audience in a productive way?
    2. Alternatively, how might this gap prevent your audience from finding your POV relevant?
  2. If there is significant overlap between one or more of your POV candidates and your audience’s POV:
    1. How might this overlap inspire or motivate your audience?
    2. If the idea is already familiar, what application, implication, or obstacle to adopting it could you help the audience explore?
  3. More generally:
    1. If you see things differently from your audience, why is that, and how can the difference benefit them?
    2. What similarities give you a useful starting point? What good reasons support the audience’s existing approach, and what would they need to understand before considering a change?

Choose one promising idea for one particular audience. What could those listeners gain by adopting it? Keep its fit with your larger audience in mind, but give yourself a specific talk to work toward.

4) POV Design And Packaging

A POV can be like a maypole or like mycelium: a prominent central feature of your speaking, or something subtler that’s diffused throughout your work. Either way, the “layer cake” from chapter 4 can help: a concise headline, a one-paragraph elaboration, and supporting material beneath them.

This form helps you clarify the idea before developing it into a talk. The headline should be true but incomplete; the paragraph fills in some nuance and reasoning. A particular talk draws from the supporting material without needing to contain everything you know.

Take your chosen candidate and write the headline and one-paragraph versions. Remember:

Then select supporting material for the talk:

5) The Fear Inventory

Now, make a written inventory of every fear — baseless or not, large or small — you feel about sharing your POV. No one else needs to see it, but don’t skip it. Writing fears down can help you examine them and decide what to do next; it doesn’t have to make them disappear to be useful.

Some fears may be about being visible, being disagreed with, or saying something imperfectly. Others may point to preparation you still need: an unsupported claim, an unanswered objection, or uncertainty about whether the idea fits this audience. Which concerns call for more work on the idea or the talk? Which discomforts might you carry with you as you try it?

6) From Strength To Strength

I hope at this point you have a promising idea, a particular audience in mind, and material you can use to explain and support it. Try a short spoken version with a few people who resemble that audience. Give them the idea, a reason to consider it, and an example or application that connects it to their circumstances.

Ask those listeners:

Use their answers to revise the idea, the supporting material, or how you connect it to the audience. If the idea is still tentative, this trial can help you decide whether to keep developing it. Choose your next opportunity to try the revised version.

Then consider how this particular talk connects to your larger audience and the work you want to develop over time:

• • •

I hope this process leaves you with an idea, an audience, a concise articulation, supporting material, and a next opportunity to try it. Keep learning from those encounters as you develop a clear, distinctive, impactful point of view. I hope that point of view creates value that both you and your audience share.

6: Conclusion

Part of making things happen is knowing they can happen. I want more of you to develop powerful, empathetic, distinctive POVs and reap their benefits. One way I can help is to show you that this is possible — and how a POV works. Thus, this guide.

I remain convinced that the best POVs emerge from focused experience and an empathetic but somewhat frustrated, impatient concern for your audience’s progress.

If you feel some POV raw material rolling around inside you but haven’t yet shaped it into an idea you can articulate, I hope this guide has helped. Stick with it! The struggle is worth it, even if it takes time to arrive at one of those crisp, impactful POVs we all admire.

Sincerely,

Philip Morgan https://philipmorgan.net

POV Exploration Prompts

Work through no more than one prompt per day. Set a timer for 20 minutes and aim for 200 words; that’s a target, not a minimum or maximum. Then publish what you’ve written on social media, to an email list, or elsewhere.


A Few Terms

Buy-in: Accepting an idea as true or useful enough to make it part of how you think. In this guide, that means adopting a POV because you believe it could make things better for you. Buy-in can precede action; agreeing with an idea doesn’t mean you’ve started using it.

Implementation: Putting an idea into practice. If buy-in is “I believe this could help,” implementation is “I’m changing what I do because of it.” That might mean trying a new behavior, changing a decision, or using the idea to guide your work.

Dissonance: The tension you feel when ideas, experiences, or actions don’t fit together. You might buy into a POV and then notice that your habits run counter to it, or encounter an experience that challenges an idea you believed. That tension can give you something to examine: should the idea change, should your actions change, or is there more to understand?

The List Of Prompts

  1. List every argument you can think of against your POV. Anything is fair game, even if its evidence is weak or its appeal purely emotional. Use a bullet list, describing each argument in a phrase or one to two short sentences. Later prompts will explore these arguments, so there’s no need to examine each in depth today.
  2. What is the strongest argument against your POV?
  3. Why is that argument the strongest?
  4. How would you invite someone to buy into your POV despite good arguments against it? Brainstorm several approaches or develop the one you think is best.
  5. What is the strongest argument for your POV?
  6. Why is that argument the strongest?
  7. Some people are ready to buy into your POV now. Others aren’t, despite the strength of your argument. What makes them “not ready yet”?
  8. What would need to happen before someone became ready to buy into your POV? Consider events, stages of maturity, or failures of other approaches.
  9. Does remaining bought in to your POV happen naturally, or is it like sticking to a difficult diet? If the latter, what could cause someone to “fall off the wagon”?
  10. How much change is required for a typical member of your audience to buy into your POV? How would you describe its magnitude or intensity?
  11. Are those who buy into your POV inclined to “sell” it to others? Why or why not?
  12. In nakedly scientific or economic terms, what do people or organizations get when they buy into your POV? Status? Profit of some kind? Power? Something else?
  13. Which word you use to communicate your POV is most likely to confuse potential adopters or make them hesitate?
  14. Is your POV part of a lineage or “family tree” of ideas? (It almost certainly is.) What are its relatives?
  15. Within that family tree, are there new or long-running “family feuds” between your POV and its close or distant relatives?
  16. At the yearly family reunion, which “POV family members” does it enjoy connecting with? Which does it try to sit close to at the dinner table? Why?
  17. When a person or organization starts acting on your POV, where will the change first show up?
  18. After buying in and changing their actions, adopters of your POV may reach a moment of heightened difficulty. Their actions may be criticized or create new problems. Write about that moment from an adopter’s perspective if you can.
  19. Return to your scientific or economic description of what people or organizations get from buying into your POV. Are the benefits ongoing or time-limited? If time-limited, when will people reach a plateau, and what will it look like? If ongoing, what makes your POV “the gift that keeps on giving”?
  20. Does buying into your POV create cognitive or other forms of dissonance?
  21. Does implementing your POV create dissonance?
  22. What might seem unrelated to your POV but be affected when people adopt it? Think of parts of a lake touched by ripples from a dropped stone.
  23. Your POV is probably not a great fit for everybody. Who should not buy into your POV? Why?
  24. If someone became excited by your POV, bought into it, and began implementing it on their own, where might they screw up the implementation?
  25. Think back over the last week. What happened to you — or what did you do — that could serve as an example or metaphor when discussing your POV? What’s the story?

Continuing the work

At the Cheryl Janis Agency, Cheryl and I help people develop what they have to say and find the right audiences for it. I work with speakers on their point of view and presentation; Cheryl builds relationships with event organizers and handles outreach and coordination.

If you’d like a thought partner for your ideas, or help finding opportunities to share them, you can learn about our work at cherylrjanis.com.


  1. Sharon Toerek, interview with Agency Management Institute, “Intellectual Property Advice,” https://agencymanagementinstitute.com/intellectual-property-advice/↩︎

  2. Ted Gudorf, “Repair the Roof” podcast, episode 22, “Funding Trusts: Top 7 Items,” https://www.daytonestateplanninglaw.com/episodes/ep-22-funding-trusts-top-7-items/↩︎

  3. InnoVint, “The Biggest Winery Financial Mistakes” panel recap, featuring Geni Whitehouse, https://www.innovint.us/insight/biggest-winery-financial-mistakes/↩︎

  4. Kristy Illuzzi and Ronald J. Baker, “Value Pricing – An Update with Ron Baker,” IFAC, April 19, 2022. https://www.ifac.org/knowledge-gateway/discussion/value-pricing-update-ron-baker↩︎

  5. Atul Gawande, “How Do We Heal Medicine?” TED2012, https://www.ted.com/talks/atul_gawande_how_do_we_heal_medicine; biography at https://atulgawande.com/about/↩︎

  6. Alex B. Haynes et al., “A Surgical Safety Checklist to Reduce Morbidity and Mortality in a Global Population,” New England Journal of Medicine 360 (2009): 491–499, https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa0810119. This prospective before-and-after study compared outcomes at eight hospitals; patients were not randomly assigned to checklist use.↩︎

  7. Sharon Toerek, interview with Agency Management Institute, “Intellectual Property Advice,” https://agencymanagementinstitute.com/intellectual-property-advice/; see also biography noting American Advertising Federation Cleveland involvement and industry panel participation, https://legalandcreative.com/about-us/our-team/about-sharon-toerek/↩︎

  8. InnoVint, “The Biggest Winery Financial Mistakes” panel recap, featuring Geni Whitehouse, https://www.innovint.us/insight/biggest-winery-financial-mistakes/↩︎

  9. Sarah Susanka, “About Sarah Susanka,” https://susanka.com/about-sarah-susanka/↩︎

  10. Sarah Susanka, “The Not So Big House,” https://susanka.com/not-so-big-house/↩︎

  11. Ron Baker, “Value Pricing Update,” IFAC, https://www.ifac.org/knowledge-gateway/discussion/value-pricing-update-ron-baker↩︎

  12. Ron Baker, “Get Beyond the Billable Hour,” Lawyerist podcast episode 400, August 11, 2022, https://lawyerist.com/podcast/get-beyond-billable-hours/ (transcript at 6:48)↩︎

  13. Sharon Toerek, interview with Agency Management Institute, “Intellectual Property Advice,” https://agencymanagementinstitute.com/intellectual-property-advice/↩︎

  14. It probably is possible to re-frame a you-centered POV like this in terms of audience wellbeing/progress. Just because it starts out you-centered doesn’t mean it needs to remain stuck there.↩︎

  15. You can benefit from the pursuit of something you do not ultimately achieve. I might benefit from running a marathon even if I come in last or can’t complete the race; the training and effort and growth it creates has value independent of the outcome.↩︎

  16. https://jonathanstark.com/hbin↩︎

  17. http://podcast.ditchinghourly.com↩︎

  18. https://jonathanstark.com/vpb↩︎